Cute Nutter Butter Thanksgiving Turkey Cookies Recipe

Cute but Nutty Thanksgiving Turkey Cookies Recipe

I am so excited to share this super cutepeCutnutty Nutty ThanksgturkeyTurkey cookie recipe with you!  Who wouldn’t love to bite into these super-cute Thanksgiving cookies?

utter Butter Thanksgiving Turkey Cookies Recipe

Not only are they fun, but they sure do look like something you could enjoy making with the kids or for your kids Thanksgiving party!

Cute Nutter Butter Thanksgiving Turkey Cookies Recipe

Cute Thanksgiving Turkey Cookies RecipeNutty Thanksgiving Turkey Cookies Recipe

I sure hope you enjoy these nutty Thanksgiving cookies!

Cute but Nutty Thanksgiving Turkey Cookies

Print
Serves: 10 Prep Time:
Nutrition facts: 200 calories 20 grams fat
Rating: 5.0/5
( 1 voted )

Ingredients

  • Turkey Cookies:
  • Package of Nutter Butter cookies
  • Container of mini candy eyes
  • Orange M&M's
  • Royal Icing:
  • 2 egg whites
  • 1 C powder sugar
  • 1/2 tsp cream of tartar
  • Red & orange gel food coloring

Instructions

Turkey Cookies:

Assembly directions for Nutter Turkey will follow instructions for royal icing.

Royal Icing:

Combine all ingredients in a mixing bowl, mixing on medium speed for 4 minutes. (except for your food coloring).

If the icing is not stiff enough, add 1/4 cup powdered sugar.

Divide the icing into thirds.

In the first bowl, add several drops of orange gel food coloring. Stir to blend.

In the second bowl, add drops of red gel food coloring, mixing well to incorporate the color.

The third bowl of icing remains white.

Pour each color of icing into individual frosting bags with a #5 tip. Twist the open end of the bag to push the icing to the tip.

Turkey Cookie Assembly:

Lay out several Nutter Butter cookies.

Separate the orange M&M's on a plate.

Pour out the mini candy eyes in a small bowl.

Using the picture of the Nutter Cookies as an outline.

After referring to the photo, decide where you want to place the eyes, make a small dot on the cookie with white icing, and place the candy eyes over the dots. Allow a few seconds for the eyes to dry.

Apply a small dot of orange icing to the area of the nose. Hold the orange M&M to the orange icing for 30 seconds until it "glues" onto it.

With the frosting bag of red icing, draw a "waddle" on the side of the turkey's face coming from the side of the orange nose.

Allow the icing to dry completely for about an hour, or until you touch the waddle and it is dry.

Notes

Recipe created for us by Krista and her crew.

Cute Thanksgiving Turkey Nutter Butter Cookies Recipe

Enough with the rambling. I sure hope you enjoy our cute but nutty Thanksgiving turkey cookie recipe!

Do you have a favorite Thanksgiving recipe or craft you like to do this time of year?

26 Comments

  1. Cristy Ridey

    These are so cute! I wish I had seen them before Thanksgiving!

  2. Cindy S.

    Oh my gosh. These are SO cute. Can’t wait to make these next year at Thanksgiving time.

  3. lisa

    These are adorable. People can be so imaginative when it comes to food presentation. This would even look great as part of a centerpiece.

  4. Deborah W

    I love these and am going to try and make some with my granddaughter this Thanksgiving.

  5. Erin will

    These are ridiculously cute!! My kids would have so much fun making these! Hope ours come out somewhat looking like turkeys! lol Thanks!!

  6. Molli Vandehey

    these are so silly! love them

  7. Megan R

    Such a cute holiday idea! A fun mix of food and crafting.

  8. sambows

    Oh my gosh these are so cute.. To bad I can`t make them for school.

  9. DJohnson

    I love these! They look tasty and super cute. My kids would enjoy them.

  10. debbiewelchert

    These are so cute. I will love making these with my grandchildren. Hopefully they will have as much fun eating them as they will be making them.

  11. alicia szemon

    these are seriously the cutest cookies ever!!

  12. Edna Williams

    So fun! These would be cute for Thanksgiving! Thanks for sharing!

  13. SandyC

    So adorable! And no hot oven to deal with! Also, I like that these can be adapted for other holidays.occasions. That’ts the stuff I really like – get a basic idea, and then change it around a bit. I can see these made for little Santas, etc. Even “Uncle Sams” for the 4th of July. Thanks!

  14. slehan

    Fun cookies with no cooking! I like that.
    slehan at juno dot com

  15. krissie

    this sounds fun to make and this is really cute

  16. Richard Hicks

    These cookies are really just too cute and everyone would love them

  17. Bill Hoff

    We are always looking for different treats to prepare our grand kids!

  18. Amber Ludwig

    Omgosh these are too fun!! My son and I would have a blast putting them together!! They’d be super cute individually wrapped with cellophane and ribbon and there to pick up at a party!!

  19. Lisa K

    These are very cute! I bet it is hard to eat only one. Good thing it’s Thanksgiving… then it’s ok to over indulge on turkey! 🙂

  20. Shannon

    These are just adorable and thanks for sharing your recipe with us.

  21. Oh my gosh how cute these are for Thanksgiving! Thanks for sharing!

  22. lisa

    Those are cute. I love nutter butter cookies. Very creative cookies!

  23. Jodi Hunter

    I love these, me and my daughter will give this a go on Thanksgiving.

  24. TrishFr

    These are so cute. I didn’t know they made candy eyes, I will have to look for them next time I am in the baking section of the store. It looks like you used some jellybeans for the feathers but I didn’t see them mentioned in the recipe.

  25. Linda Manns Linneman

    These are so cute. Almost to cute to eat. We will give these a try. Thank you so much for sharing

  26. Nicole Carter Weasley

    These are absolutely adorable! Thanks for sharing! Happy Thanksgiving!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *